• Latest

Senate Perspectives: Eat Your Peas

February 28, 2017

Montpelier Police Dept. Virtual Reality Training System

May 24, 2022

Gifford to Offer Teens a Safe Sitter® Course

May 24, 2022
Vermont Foodbank Chief Financial Officer Julie-Ann Graves, 2022 Winner of the Remarkable Woman

Vermont Foodbank Chief Financial Officer Julie-Ann Graves, 2022 Winner of the Remarkable Woman

May 24, 2022
Barre Lions Club Community News

Barre Lions Club Community News

May 24, 2022
African Queen (1951)

From Here to Eternity (1953)

May 24, 2022
Student Artwork Graces Downtown Storefront

Student Artwork Graces Downtown Storefront

May 17, 2022
Vermont Plants Sunflowers for Ukraine Solidarity Update

Vermont Plants Sunflowers for Ukraine Solidarity Update

May 17, 2022

Upper Valley Everyone Eats Returns to Gifford in May

May 17, 2022
African Queen (1951)

Some Like it Hot (1959)

May 17, 2022
Just Some Thoughts

A Million Little Miracles

May 17, 2022
Young Wildlife Belong in the Wild

Young Wildlife Belong in the Wild

May 10, 2022
Make-A-Wish® Crowns Best Beard in Vermont and Raises Over $90,000 at Sixth Annual Vermont Beardies

Make-A-Wish® Crowns Best Beard in Vermont and Raises Over $90,000 at Sixth Annual Vermont Beardies

May 10, 2022
  • Home
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy
  • Sitemap
Thursday, May 26, 2022
The World Online
Advertisement
  • Home
  • News & Features
    • Local News
    • Letters & opinions
    • George Shuman
    • Max’s View
    • Local Sports & Outdoors
    • Births
    • Weddings & Engagements
  • Calendar
    • Art Exhibits
    • Calendar of Events
    • Ongoing Events
  • Obituaries
  • Submit
    • Submit Calendar Listing for Non-Profit Events
    • Submit An Article To The World
    • Submit Letter To The Editor
    • Submit Sports News/Photo
    • Submit Birth Announcement
    • Submit Engagement Announcement
    • Submit Wedding Announcement
  • Advertising
    • World Rates and Ad Sizes
    • World Distribution Map
    • World Deadlines
    • Audit and Reader Surveys
    • Advertising Inquiry
  • Classifieds
    • Place Classified Ads
    • View Current Classifieds
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News & Features
    • Local News
    • Letters & opinions
    • George Shuman
    • Max’s View
    • Local Sports & Outdoors
    • Births
    • Weddings & Engagements
  • Calendar
    • Art Exhibits
    • Calendar of Events
    • Ongoing Events
  • Obituaries
  • Submit
    • Submit Calendar Listing for Non-Profit Events
    • Submit An Article To The World
    • Submit Letter To The Editor
    • Submit Sports News/Photo
    • Submit Birth Announcement
    • Submit Engagement Announcement
    • Submit Wedding Announcement
  • Advertising
    • World Rates and Ad Sizes
    • World Distribution Map
    • World Deadlines
    • Audit and Reader Surveys
    • Advertising Inquiry
  • Classifieds
    • Place Classified Ads
    • View Current Classifieds
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
The World Online
No Result
View All Result

Senate Perspectives: Eat Your Peas

vt-world by vt-world
February 28, 2017
in Letters & opinions
0

By Joe Benning
State Senator, Caledonia District

“But Mom, I don’t like peas,” said my 5-year-old self to my mother. “Eat them anyway,” came her response. “But Mom, they don’t taste good,” I pled, hoping to gain some sympathy. She replied with a sympathy thrust of her own: “Be thankful you have them, there are starving people in the world, you know.” “Well, they can have my peas,” I retorted with juvenile logic. “Eat those peas,” came her stern response. “But why?” Her voice rose a notch: “Because I’m your mother and I said so!” That pretty much ended the discussion.

That 55-year-old conversation popped into my head recently as I listened to a rather tortuous debate on the floor of Vermont’s House of Representatives. The question was whether the House should exercise its constitutional authority to hold a second recount requested by defeated House candidate Susan Hatch Davis. Logic was at war with naked power. It was a difficult thing to watch.

The facts are not all that complicated. In the election of 2016, Republican newcomer Bob Frenier beat five-term Progressive incumbent Hatch Davis by eight votes in a six-town legislative district in Orange County. Hatch Davis asked for a recount. The recount was conducted by vote tabulator under the supervision of the county clerk. In the recount, Frenier’s margin of victory shrank to seven votes. Hatch Davis then brought a claim for a second recount or a new election in Orange Superior Court. The judge rejected her claim and affirmed the election’s results. The Secretary of State certified Frenier’s election, he was sworn in and he took his seat in the House.

But Hatch Davis had one more option: appealing directly to the House of Representatives, which under the Vermont Constitution has authority to “judge of the elections and qualifications of its members” pursuant to Chapter II, Section 14. The House decided to take it up, and here’s where one is reminded of having to swallow something you don’t like while there are starving people in the world.

The issue came before the House Government Operations committee, which decided it would not take up Hatch Davis’s rather unusual claim that so-called “defective ballots” should be reviewed. That was really the only substantive claim she had. With that eliminated, only vague possibilities remained. The committee chair, Democrat Maida Townsend, surmised: “We know if the visual inspection is not paired with the tabulator, it is possible that votes may have been missed.” One would therefore anticipate that the committee would take testimony from the people who actually oversaw the insertion of ballots into the tabulator to see if there was evidence of such. But they weren’t invited. Not surprisingly, a rather contentious committee discussion then broke along party lines. The Republicans asked: “So then why are we doing this?” The Democrats’ response can be whittled down to: “Because we can.” With a dominant Democratic majority, the decision was made to go forward recommending the House conduct a recount and Republican objections were for naught.

Then it got interesting. The town clerks who oversaw the recount, denied opportunity to testify, fired off a letter claiming Townsend was wrong. Hardworking town clerks from around the state expressed anger that their integrity was being questioned. Court certification was apparently not relevant to the discussion. Secretary of State Jim Condos, himself a Democrat, shook his head in dismay at the bad precedent being established by the House deciding to hold a recount simply because it had that power.

In the middle of over five hours of House debate, Representative Kurt Wright posed a simple question. “Madam Speaker, I know we can do this, but the question is should we?” In the House gallery my mind suddenly wandered back to a plate of squishy, canned peas. Wright’s fair question was answered with blatant politics, as the overwhelming Democratic majority decided to press ahead with yet another recount in the absence of a reason to do so. With no specific evidence of wrongdoing, their decision impugns the integrity of those town clerks who conducted a fair election and subsequent recount. It dismisses a court opinion, and goes against the certification of the Secretary of State. Most importantly, it sets a terrible precedent whereby future legislatures will be unable to refuse any disgruntled candidate who asks the legislature for relief when there is no justification for doing so.

Shortly before she died, my mother said she regretted forcing me to eat those peas. I obediently ate them in silence, but she confessed it was hard for her to watch me do so while tears streamed down my face.

Previous Post

Quality Afterschool and Summer Programs should be Available to all Vermonters

Next Post

Max’s View

Next Post

Max’s View

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This Week’s Ads

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy
  • Sitemap
The World
403 US Route 302
Barre, VT 05641
Phone: (802) 479-2582

Copyright © 2019 The World Online. All Rights Reserved. Powered by CoolerAds.

No Result
View All Result
  • Art Exhibits
  • Audit and Reader Surveys
  • Births
  • Calendar
  • Contact Us
  • Daily Horoscope
  • Fall Guide
  • Food & Recipe
  • Home
  • Obituaries
  • Ongoing Events
  • Pay Your Bill Here
  • Senior Living Edition
  • Showtimes
  • Submit Birth Announcement
  • Submit Calendar Listing for Non-Profit Events
  • Submit Engagement Announcement
  • Submit Listing to our Local Directory
  • Submit Sports News/Photo
  • Submit Wedding Announcement
  • Testimonials
  • The World Coupons
  • Weather Forecast
  • World Deadlines
  • World Distribution Map
  • World Rate Card
  • World Rates and Ad Sizes
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy
  • Sitemap
  • About Us
  • Vermont Lottery
  • Advertising Information
  • The World Staff
  • Advertising Inquiry
  • Submit Letter To The Editor
  • Local Directory
  • Poll Results
  • Local Deals
  • Classifieds
  • Submit An Article To The World
  • Events
  • The World – This Week’s Online Digital Edition
  • The World Auto & Sports

Copyright © 2019 The World Online. All Rights Reserved. Powered by CoolerAds.

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In