• Latest

Guest Opinion:Legislators Should Stand With Voters

March 26, 2018

VT Department of Labor Provides Update on Mailing of New 1099-G Tax Forms to Unemployment Claimants

March 2, 2021
“Sam & Jim in Hell” – Reading of a New Play by Jeanne Beckwith

“Sam & Jim in Hell” – Reading of a New Play by Jeanne Beckwith

March 2, 2021
Just Some Thoughts

Cabin Fever Relievers

March 2, 2021
Mayor’s Report – September 2019

Mayor’s Report – February 2021

March 2, 2021

Tokyo Story (1953)

March 2, 2021

VSAC Shows You How: Comparing Financial Aid Offers

February 23, 2021

Eraserhead (1977) 3 Stars

February 23, 2021

Public Health Leaders Urge Vermont Legislators to Prevent the Sale of All Flavored Tobacco Products

February 23, 2021

Bernie’s Mitten Merchandise Offers A Pathway Out of Poverty

February 23, 2021

Enjoy the 2021 Maple Season, Even Without Maple Open House Weekend

February 23, 2021
Plainfield’s Community Bagged Supper Resumes on February 23rd

Plainfield’s Community Bagged Supper Resumes on February 23rd

February 16, 2021

2021 Vermont Personal Income Tax Season Now Open

February 16, 2021
  • Home
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy
  • Sitemap
Friday, March 5, 2021
The World Online
  • Home
  • News & Features
    • Local News
    • Letters & opinions
    • George Shuman
    • Max’s View
    • Local Sports & Outdoors
    • Births
    • Weddings & Engagements
  • Calendar
    • Art Exhibits
    • Calendar of Events
    • Ongoing Events
  • Obituaries
  • Submit
    • Submit Calendar Listing
    • Submit An Article To The World
    • Submit Letter To The Editor
    • Submit Sports News/Photo
    • Submit Birth Announcement
    • Submit Engagement Announcement
    • Submit Wedding Announcement
  • Advertising
    • World Rates and Ad Sizes
    • World Distribution Map
    • World Deadlines
    • Audit and Reader Surveys
    • Advertising Inquiry
  • Classifieds
    • Place Classified Ads
    • View Current Classifieds
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News & Features
    • Local News
    • Letters & opinions
    • George Shuman
    • Max’s View
    • Local Sports & Outdoors
    • Births
    • Weddings & Engagements
  • Calendar
    • Art Exhibits
    • Calendar of Events
    • Ongoing Events
  • Obituaries
  • Submit
    • Submit Calendar Listing
    • Submit An Article To The World
    • Submit Letter To The Editor
    • Submit Sports News/Photo
    • Submit Birth Announcement
    • Submit Engagement Announcement
    • Submit Wedding Announcement
  • Advertising
    • World Rates and Ad Sizes
    • World Distribution Map
    • World Deadlines
    • Audit and Reader Surveys
    • Advertising Inquiry
  • Classifieds
    • Place Classified Ads
    • View Current Classifieds
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
The World Online
No Result
View All Result

Guest Opinion:Legislators Should Stand With Voters

vt-world by vt-world
March 26, 2018
in Letters & opinions
0

By Allen Gilbert

There have been some very good ideas, and some very bad ideas, over the years about changing the state’s education funding system.

One of the best ideas came more than a hundred years ago, when Gov. William Dillingham proposed a statewide education tax to equalize school resources across the state. Some school districts had tax rates eight times higher than others. In 1890, the legislature approved a 5-percent surcharge on local property tax bills, with the funds redistributed to towns in need. This statewide property tax remained in place until 1931. Repeal was based partly on what legislators came to see as the bad idea behind the tax – its reliance on taxing property rather than income or other assets.

In 1947, Gov. Ernest Gibson Sr. told the legislature the greatest problem facing the state’s education system was “equalizing educational opportunity and distributing the costs as equally as possible among the towns and school districts of the State.”

For the next 50 years, Vermont struggled with the problem that Gibson identified, and with addressing the problem faced by the hardest-hit taxpayers, the income-poor — people deemed “property rich” because they owned a farm or woodlands but earned little income.

The result was a succession of different funding systems and one of the Legislature’s best ideas: the state’s property tax rebate program, which limits low-income Vermonters’ property tax bills to no more than 5 percent of their incomes, enacted in the 1970s. Twenty-five years later this program was integrated into the funding system with “income sensitivity.” Two-thirds of Vermont homeowners now pay their school taxes based on their income.

One of the worst ideas discussed this legislative session has been elimination of income sensitivity. Despite the rhetoric that legislators were trying to shift more of school costs to the income tax, the long-term impact of eliminating income-sensitivity would have ultimately put us right back where we learned from experience we shouldn’t go – greater reliance on the property tax.

The final tax reform proposal to come before the House, H. 911, avoids the worst changes considered by the House Ways and Means Committee. But the bill as written still has some very bad ideas that are a step backward, not forward, in school funding reform.

The very worst idea of all in H. 911 is eliminating the current direct relation between spending per pupil and a town’s tax rate. Now, if spending per pupil increases by 5 percent, then the town’s school tax rate goes up 5 percent. The bill tosses that out. For some towns, tax rates could go up twice as fast as spending per pupil; for others, three times. This type of change does not support local school districts. It causes confusion and frustration.

Town meeting voters got it right this year, and the legislature and governor should listen. School boards did what the governor asked them to do, and then some. Nearly all school budgets passed.

The real “problem” with the current school funding formula is that it has worked better and lasted longer than any other formula. You know that’s the case when opponents trot out the trope that it’s time to review the formula not because a fundamental flaw has been identified but because an arbitrary number of years have passed — and therefore it must be time to open the hood and start tinkering.

We should all be wary of ideas justified by the mantra, “It’s time for a change”. If real reasons for change are identified, real solutions can be discussed and hammered out. That’s when change is justified. But that’s not happening.

The shove from the Vermont Supreme Court in its 1997 Brigham decision moved Vermont a huge distance towards achieving Gov. Gibson’s goal of creating an equitable system for funding schools. Although not perfect, Vermont’s current formula is considered the country’s fairest. Now is not the time for a retreat. H. 911 would be a step back from the achievements past governors and legislatures only dreamed of.

Allen Gilbert of Worcester was chair of his town’s school board when it joined the ACLU’s Brigham lawsuit in 1995. He has remained active in education issues.

Previous Post

“Competitive” Crow Shoot? Try Using Beer Cans for Target Practice Instead

Next Post

Guest Opinion:Business Planning 101

Next Post

Guest Opinion:Business Planning 101

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This Week’s Ads

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy
  • Sitemap
The World
403 US Route 302
Barre, VT 05641
Phone: (802) 479-2582

Copyright © 2019 The World Online. All Rights Reserved. Powered by CoolerAds.

No Result
View All Result
  • Art Exhibits
  • Audit and Reader Surveys
  • Births
  • Calendar
  • Contact Us
  • Daily Horoscope
  • Fall Dining Guide
  • Food & Recipe
  • Home
  • Obituaries
  • Ongoing Events
  • Pay Your Bill Here
  • Senior Living Edition
  • Showtimes
  • Submit Birth Announcement
  • Submit Calendar Listing
  • Submit Engagement Announcement
  • Submit Listing to our Local Directory
  • Submit Sports News/Photo
  • Submit Wedding Announcement
  • Testimonials
  • The World Coupons
  • Weather Forecast
  • World Deadlines
  • World Distribution Map
  • World Rate Card
  • World Rates and Ad Sizes
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy
  • Sitemap
  • About Us
  • Vermont Lottery
  • Advertising Information
  • The World Staff
  • Advertising Inquiry
  • Submit Letter To The Editor
  • Local Directory
  • Poll Results
  • Local Deals
  • Classifieds
  • Submit An Article To The World
  • Events
  • The World – This Week’s Online Digital Edition
  • The World Auto & Sports

Copyright © 2019 The World Online. All Rights Reserved. Powered by CoolerAds.

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In