• Latest

Guest Opinion: The Culture of Trump Comes to Vermont

August 8, 2016

Dirty Harry (1971)

January 21, 2021
F&W’s 2021 Conservation Camp Registration is Open

F&W’s 2021 Conservation Camp Registration is Open

January 19, 2021
Ice Fishing FUNdamentals How to Enjoy Yourself and Stay Safe on the Ice This Winter

Ice Fishing FUNdamentals How to Enjoy Yourself and Stay Safe on the Ice This Winter

January 19, 2021
This Old House

Mouse in the House

January 19, 2021

Buffalo Plaid Fundraiser to Support Local Nonprofits

January 19, 2021

Free Tax Filing at Capstone Community Action for Tax Year 2020

January 19, 2021

Leahy-Led Bipartisan Bill Promoting Affordable Health Insurance Is Signed Into Law

January 19, 2021

Vermont State Labor Council, AFL-CIO Hires First Female Executive Director, Signaling New Direction for VT Labor Movement

January 12, 2021

Vermont Mutual Distributes $1,000,000 to COVID-19 Relief Efforts

January 12, 2021
Hunters Take 6,136 Turkeys in Vermont in 2020

Hunters Take 6,136 Turkeys in Vermont in 2020

January 12, 2021
Additional Ounce, Priority Mail and Postcard Stamps Available Jan. 24

Additional Ounce, Priority Mail and Postcard Stamps Available Jan. 24

January 12, 2021
One Credit Union Donates $12K to Make-A-Wish

One Credit Union Donates $12K to Make-A-Wish

January 12, 2021
  • Home
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy
  • Sitemap
Sunday, January 24, 2021
The World Online
  • Home
  • News & Features
    • Local News
    • Letters & opinions
    • George Shuman
    • Max’s View
    • Local Sports & Outdoors
    • Births
    • Weddings & Engagements
  • Calendar
    • Art Exhibits
    • Calendar of Events
    • Ongoing Events
  • Obituaries
  • Submit
    • Submit Calendar Listing
    • Submit An Article To The World
    • Submit Letter To The Editor
    • Submit Sports News/Photo
    • Submit Birth Announcement
    • Submit Engagement Announcement
    • Submit Wedding Announcement
  • Advertising
    • World Rates and Ad Sizes
    • World Distribution Map
    • World Deadlines
    • Audit and Reader Surveys
    • Advertising Inquiry
  • Classifieds
    • Place Classified Ads
    • View Current Classifieds
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News & Features
    • Local News
    • Letters & opinions
    • George Shuman
    • Max’s View
    • Local Sports & Outdoors
    • Births
    • Weddings & Engagements
  • Calendar
    • Art Exhibits
    • Calendar of Events
    • Ongoing Events
  • Obituaries
  • Submit
    • Submit Calendar Listing
    • Submit An Article To The World
    • Submit Letter To The Editor
    • Submit Sports News/Photo
    • Submit Birth Announcement
    • Submit Engagement Announcement
    • Submit Wedding Announcement
  • Advertising
    • World Rates and Ad Sizes
    • World Distribution Map
    • World Deadlines
    • Audit and Reader Surveys
    • Advertising Inquiry
  • Classifieds
    • Place Classified Ads
    • View Current Classifieds
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
The World Online
No Result
View All Result

Guest Opinion: The Culture of Trump Comes to Vermont

vt-world by vt-world
August 8, 2016
in Letters & opinions
0

By Carl Etnier
I’ve been talking with quite a few voters recently, and a number of people have raised questions about a recent decision by the Public Service Board (PSB) to exclude the public from an Aug. 4 hearing about the Vermont Gas pipeline. These voters are right to be concerned.

The pipeline is a $166 million step in the wrong direction. It makes Vermont more dependent on importing fracked natural gas, at a time when we’re working to get 90% of our energy from renewables by 2050. It’s a big deal. Excluding the public from a hearing like this is the sort of move I’d expect from a Trump presidency, not from a board created by Vermont lawmakers.

The PSB’s reasons for excluding the public were that they feared protestors would disrupt the hearing. The fear is not unfounded. At prehearing conferences related to the pipeline, the PSB notes, members of the public shouted and sang loudly, which made it difficult to hear each other and get anything done.

The PSB sought advice from the parties in the case about how to conduct business with all these folks singing and shouting. And then the PSB devised a solution that was more anti-democratic than anyone it consulted with contemplated. Not even Vermont Gas asked for the public to be excluded altogether.

Initially, the PSB was going to allow the press and the public to listen in on the hearing via phone. Anyone who has ever phoned into a live meeting knows how much is missed by not seeing facial expressions and body language—or often not being able to tell who a speaker is.

The PSB modified its order, so members of the press were allowed to attend in person. And a YouTube channel broadcasted the hearing live to anyone with a computer and broadband—at least that portion of the hearing the camera(s) happen to be pointed at.

A YouTube stream does not give as much information as being there in the room. The PSB implicitly acknowledges this by allowing the press into the hearing room. Since the press gets more information by being in the room, they can do better reporting for the rest of us.

The general public was given a choice of experiencing the hearing through the filter of the YouTube stream or the filter of the press in attendance.

Are the folks who have been shouting and singing loudly interested in observing the PSB activities? Surely not; they’re interested in disrupting the whole permitting process. But government has a responsibility to keep its meetings open and transparent to those who are interested in observing. Closing the door on everyone because of some protests is a form of collective punishment, inappropriate for a democracy. You and I and everyone else are targeted by an order that, rightfully, should be targeted only at people who are actually disrupting the hearing. The Burlington Free Press says the PSB’s response makes it appear “arrogant and weak,” and they’re right.

The legislature doesn’t shut out the public from the Statehouse when there are protests—they simply beef up security. The PSB opted not to remove just the people disrupting the hearing, saying it would take a lot of cops to do so. Well, OK. That’s a price of democracy.

The Secretary of State’s office has said the PSB is allowed to close its hearings to the public, since it’s a “quasi-judicial” entity. Pipeline opponent and attorney Lisa Barrett has filed a case in federal court to open up the hearing. If it turns out that neither Vermont statute nor the federal courts protect the public’s right to attend PSB hearings, it’s imperative that Vermont lawmakers open up the doors of the PSB and let more sunshine in.

Carl Etnier works at Goddard College Community Radio and is running for legislature to represent East Montpelier and Middlesex.

Previous Post

Financial Security for our Senior Citizens

Next Post

Mirror Lake is Alarmingly Polluted

Next Post

Mirror Lake is Alarmingly Polluted

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This Week’s Ads

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy
  • Sitemap
The World
403 US Route 302
Barre, VT 05641
Phone: (802) 479-2582

Copyright © 2019 The World Online. All Rights Reserved. Powered by CoolerAds.

No Result
View All Result
  • Art Exhibits
  • Audit and Reader Surveys
  • Births
  • Calendar
  • Contact Us
  • Daily Horoscope
  • Fall Dining Guide
  • Food & Recipe
  • Home
  • Obituaries
  • Ongoing Events
  • Pay Your Bill Here
  • Senior Living Edition
  • Showtimes
  • Submit Birth Announcement
  • Submit Calendar Listing
  • Submit Engagement Announcement
  • Submit Listing to our Local Directory
  • Submit Sports News/Photo
  • Submit Wedding Announcement
  • Testimonials
  • The World Coupons
  • Weather Forecast
  • World Deadlines
  • World Distribution Map
  • World Rate Card
  • World Rates and Ad Sizes
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy
  • Sitemap
  • About Us
  • Vermont Lottery
  • Advertising Information
  • The World Staff
  • Advertising Inquiry
  • Submit Letter To The Editor
  • Local Directory
  • Poll Results
  • Local Deals
  • Classifieds
  • Submit An Article To The World
  • Events
  • The World – This Week’s Online Digital Edition
  • The World Auto & Sports

Copyright © 2019 The World Online. All Rights Reserved. Powered by CoolerAds.

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In